Skip to Main Content
Skip to Navigation
Accessibility Statement
Home
About the Board
Members
Annual Reports and Board Remuneration
Career Opportunities
How to Appeal
Appeal Process
Rules and Practice Directives
Information Sheets
Prepare for a Hearing
Hearing Schedule
Decisions
CCALAB Decisions
Decisions 2004 – Earlier
Judicial Review Decisions
Resources
Legislation and Regulations
Additional Resources
Frequently Asked Questions
Home
ยป
CCALAB Decisions
Search
Search
Preliminary and Final Decisions
Ofra Sixto (operating as ICARE Childcare Inc.) v. Dr. Meena Dawar, Medical Health Officer, Vancouver Coastal Health Authority
Decision Type:
FINAL DECISION
Decision Outcome:
APPEALS ALLOWED
Act:
Community Care and Assisted Living Act
Date Decision Issued:
April 12, 2023
File Number:
CCALB-CCA-21-A001, 2019-CCA-004
Decision Number:
CCALB-CCA-21-A001(b), 2019-CCA-004(e)
File:
https://www.bcccalab.ca/app/uploads/sites/776/2023/04/CCALB-CCA-21-A001b_2019-CCA-004e.pdf
Ghalia Rebei Adlani (Moonlight Daycare) v. Dr. Emily Newhouse, Medical Health Officer, Fraser Health Authority
Decision Type:
FINAL DECISION
Decision Outcome:
APPEAL DISMISSED
Act:
Community Care and Assisted Living Act
Date Decision Issued:
February 7, 2023
File Number:
CCALB-CCA-21-A003
Decision Number:
CCALB-CCA-21-A003(d)
File:
https://www.bcccalab.ca/app/uploads/sites/776/2023/02/CCALB-CCA-21-A003d.pdf
Ghalia Rebei Adlani (Moonlight Daycare) v. Dr. Emily Newhouse, Medical Health Officer, Fraser Health Authority
Decision Type:
Application to Reconsider Decision to Lift Temporary Suspension
Decision Outcome:
DENIED
Act:
Community Care and Assisted Living Act
Date Decision Issued:
May 30, 2022
File Number:
CCALB-CCA-21-A003
Decision Number:
CCALB-CCA-21-A003(c)
File:
https://www.bcccalab.ca/app/uploads/sites/776/2022/06/CCALB-CCA-21-A003c.pdf
Ghalia Rebei Adlani (Moonlight Daycare) v. Dr. Emily Newhouse, Medical Health Officer, Fraser Health Authority
Decision Type:
Decision Regarding Application to Lift Temporary Suspension
Decision Outcome:
GRANTED
Act:
Community Care and Assisted Living Act
Date Decision Issued:
May 2, 2022
File Number:
CCALB-CCA-21-A003
Decision Number:
CCALB-CCA-21-A003(b)
File:
https://www.bcccalab.ca/app/uploads/sites/776/2022/05/CCALB-CCA-21-A003b.pdf
Safwana Ahmed v. Vancouver Coastal Health Authority
Decision Type:
FINAL DECISON
Decision Outcome:
Appeal allowed. Remitted back to Respondent with direction
Act:
Community Care and Assisted Living Act
Date Decision Issued:
March 18, 2022
File Number:
2019-CCA-003
Decision Number:
2019-CCA-003(e)
File:
https://www.bcccalab.ca/app/uploads/sites/776/2022/03/2019cca003e-1.pdf
Ghalia Rebel Adlani (Moonlight Daycare) v. Dr. Emily Newhouse, Medical Health Officer, Fraser Health Authority
Decision Type:
DECISION REGARDING APPLICATION FOR A TEMPORARY SUSPENSION
Decision Outcome:
GRANTED
Act:
Community Care and Assisted Living Act
Date Decision Issued:
October 21, 2021
File Number:
CCALB-CCA-21-A003
Decision Number:
CCALB-CCA-21-A003(a)
File:
https://www.bcccalab.ca/app/uploads/sites/776/2021/11/CCALB-CCA-21-A003a.pdf
Safwana Ahmed v. Vancouver Coastal Health Authority
Decision Type:
Preliminary Decision Regarding Application for Disclosure
Decision Outcome:
ORDERED
Act:
Community Care and Assisted Living Act
Date Decision Issued:
May 19, 2021
File Number:
2019-CCA-003
Decision Number:
2019-CCA-003(d)
File:
https://www.bcccalab.ca/app/uploads/sites/776/2021/06/2019cca003d.pdf
Safwana Ahmed v. Vancouver Coastal Health Authority
Decision Type:
Preliminary Decision Regarding Application for Disclosure and Cross-Examination on Affidavits
Decision Outcome:
ORDERED
Act:
Community Care and Assisted Living Act
Date Decision Issued:
October 13, 2020
File Number:
2019-CCA-003
Decision Number:
2019-CCA-003(c)
File:
https://www.bcccalab.ca/app/uploads/sites/776/2020/10/2019cca003c.pdf
Ofra Sixto (operating as ICARE Childcare Inc.) v. Vancouver Coastal Health Authority
Decision Type:
Decision Regarding Preliminary and Interim Matters – Request for Stay
Decision Outcome:
DENIED
Act:
Community Care and Assisted Living Act
Date Decision Issued:
August 5, 2020
File Number:
2019-CCA-004
Decision Number:
2019-CCA-004(c)
File:
https://www.bcccalab.ca/app/uploads/sites/776/2020/10/2019cca004c.pdf
Society of Richmond Children’s Centres v. Vancouver Coastal Health Authority
Decision Type:
Preliminary Decision on Form of Hearing
Decision Outcome:
Appeal adjourned until oral hearing can be conducted
Act:
Community Care and Assisted Living Act
Date Decision Issued:
July 17, 2020
File Number:
CCALB-CCA-20-A002
Decision Number:
CCALB-CCA-20-A002(a)
File:
https://www.bcccalab.ca/app/uploads/sites/776/2020/11/CCALB-CCA-20-A002a.pdf
Safwana Ahmed v. Vancouver Coastal Health Authority
Decision Type:
Preliminary Decison Regarding Recusal of Panel Member
Decision Outcome:
DISMISSED
Act:
Community Care and Assisted Living Act
Date Decision Issued:
June 19, 2020
File Number:
2019-CCA-003
Decision Number:
2019-CCA-003(b)
File:
https://www.bcccalab.ca/app/uploads/sites/776/2021/06/2019cca003b.pdf
Ofra Sixto (operating as ICARE Childcare Inc.) v. Vancouver Coastal Health Authority
Decision Type:
Preliminary Decision on Form of Hearing
Decision Outcome:
APPEAL ADJOURNED UNTIL ORAL HEARING CAN BE CONDUCTED
Act:
Community Care and Assisted Living Act
Date Decision Issued:
May 7, 2020
File Number:
2019-CCA-004
Decision Number:
2019-CCA-004(b)
File:
https://www.bcccalab.ca/app/uploads/sites/776/2020/10/2019cca004b.pdf
Safwana Ahmed v. Vancouver Coastal Health Authority
Decision Type:
PRELIMINARY DECISION ON FORM OF HEARING
Decision Outcome:
Act:
Community Care and Assisted Living Act
Date Decision Issued:
April 22, 2020
File Number:
2019-CCA-003
Decision Number:
2019-CCA-003(a)
File:
https://www.bcccalab.ca/app/uploads/sites/776/2020/10/2019cca003a.pdf
Ofra Sixto (operating as ICARE Childcare Inc.) v. Vancouver Coastal Health Authority
Decision Type:
APPLICATION FOR SUMMARY DISMISSAL
Decision Outcome:
DISMISSED
Act:
Community Care and Assisted Living Act
Date Decision Issued:
March 31, 2020
File Number:
2019-CCA-004
Decision Number:
2019-CCA-004(a)
File:
https://www.bcccalab.ca/app/uploads/sites/776/2020/10/2019cca004a.pdf
Society of Richmond Children’s Centres v. Vancouver Coastal Health Authority
Decision Type:
PRELIMINARY APPLICATION RE JURISDICTION AND STAY
Decision Outcome:
APPEAL DISMISSED AND REQUEST FOR STAY DENIED
Act:
Community Care and Assisted Living Act
Date Decision Issued:
September 20, 2019
File Number:
2019-CCA-002
Decision Number:
2019-CCA-002(a)
File:
https://www.bcccalab.ca/app/uploads/sites/776/2020/07/2019cca002a.pdf
Joanne Hodgins v. Director, Early Childhood Educator Registry
Decision Type:
PRELIMINARY APPLICATION FOR STAY
Decision Outcome:
APPLICATION DENIED
Act:
Community Care and Assisted Living Act
Date Decision Issued:
May 4, 2018
File Number:
2018-CCA-002
Decision Number:
2018-CCA-002(a)
File:
https://www.bcccalab.ca/app/uploads/sites/776/2020/07/2018cca002a.pdf
Culbert v. Island Health
Decision Type:
PRELIMINARY ISSUE OF JURISDICTION
Decision Outcome:
APPEAL DISMISSED
Act:
Community Care and Assisted Living Act
Date Decision Issued:
March 19, 2018
File Number:
2018-CCA-001
Decision Number:
2018-CCA-001(a)
File:
https://www.bcccalab.ca/app/uploads/sites/776/2020/07/2018cca001a.pdf
Au-Yeung v. Dr. James Lu (Vancouver Coastal Health)
Decision Type:
APPLICATION TO RECEIVE DOCUMENTS IN CONFIDENCE UNDER s. 42 OF THE ATA
Decision Outcome:
GRANTED
Act:
Community Care and Assisted Living Act
Date Decision Issued:
June 9, 2017
File Number:
2017-CCA-001
Decision Number:
2017-CCA-001(a)
File:
https://www.bcccalab.ca/app/uploads/sites/776/2020/07/2017cca001a.pdf
KN v. Interior Health Authority
Decision Type:
FINAL DECISION
Decision Outcome:
APPEAL DISMISSED
Act:
Community Care and Assisted Living Act
Date Decision Issued:
April 4, 2017
File Number:
2016-CCA-001
Decision Number:
2016-CCA-001(a)
File:
https://www.bcccalab.ca/app/uploads/sites/776/2020/07/2016cca001a.pdf
X v. Y Health Authority
Decision Type:
FINAL DECISION
Decision Outcome:
APPEAL DISMISSED
Act:
Community Care and Assisted Living Act
Date Decision Issued:
December 24, 2016
File Number:
2015-CCA-002
Decision Number:
2015-CCA-002(b)
File:
https://www.bcccalab.ca/app/uploads/sites/776/2020/07/2015cca002b.pdf
ZHH v. Interior Health
Decision Type:
APPLICATION FOR SUMMARY DISMISSAL
Decision Outcome:
GRANTED; APPEAL DISMISSED
Act:
Community Care and Assisted Living Act
Date Decision Issued:
August 18, 2016
File Number:
2014-CCA-005
Decision Number:
2014-CCA-005(d)
File:
https://www.bcccalab.ca/app/uploads/sites/776/2020/07/2014cca005d.pdf
ZHH v. Interior Health
Decision Type:
APPLICATIONS FOR STAY OF PROCEEDINGS AND SUMMARY DISMISSAL
Decision Outcome:
DENIED
Act:
Community Care and Assisted Living Act
Date Decision Issued:
June 24, 2016
File Number:
2014-CCA-005
Decision Number:
2014-CCA-005(c)
File:
https://www.bcccalab.ca/app/uploads/sites/776/2020/07/2014cca005c.pdf
X v. Y Health Authority
Decision Type:
APPLICATION TO RECEIVE DOCUMENTS IN CONFIDENCE UNDER S. 42 OF THE ATA
Decision Outcome:
DISCLOSURE OF DOCUMENTS ORDERED ON CONDITIONS
Act:
Community Care and Assisted Living Act
Date Decision Issued:
September 29, 2015
File Number:
2015-CCA-002
Decision Number:
2015-CCA-002(a)
File:
https://www.bcccalab.ca/app/uploads/sites/776/2020/07/2015cca002a.pdf
ASMSM Canada Investment Inc. v. Assisted Living Registrar
Decision Type:
APPLICATION FOR SUMMARY DISMISSAL
Decision Outcome:
GRANTED
Act:
Community Care and Assisted Living Act
Date Decision Issued:
June 9, 2015
File Number:
2014-CCA-002
Decision Number:
2014-CCA-002(a)
File:
https://www.bcccalab.ca/app/uploads/sites/776/2020/07/2014cca002a.pdf
ZHH v. Interior Health
Decision Type:
PRELIMINARY DECISION REGARDING RESPONDENT’S APPEAL RECORD AND APPELLANT’S PRELIMINARY STATEMENT OF POINTS
Decision Outcome:
Act:
Community Care and Assisted Living Act
Date Decision Issued:
May 13, 2015
File Number:
2014-CCA-005
Decision Number:
2014-CCA-004(b)
File:
https://www.bcccalab.ca/app/uploads/sites/776/2020/07/2014cca005b.pdf
ZHH v. Interior Health
Decision Type:
APPLICATION FOR INTERIM STAY ORDER PENDING APPEAL
Decision Outcome:
DENIED
Act:
Community Care and Assisted Living Act
Date Decision Issued:
December 22, 2014
File Number:
2014-CCA-005
Decision Number:
2014-CCA-005(a)
File:
https://www.bcccalab.ca/app/uploads/sites/776/2020/07/2014cca005a.pdf
AMS v. Vancouver Island Health Authority
Decision Type:
FINAL DECISION
Decision Outcome:
APPEAL DISMISSED
Act:
Community Care and Assisted Living Act
Date Decision Issued:
December 17, 2014
File Number:
2012-CCA-002
Decision Number:
2012-CCA-002(b)
File:
https://www.bcccalab.ca/app/uploads/sites/776/2020/07/2012cca002b.pdf
CM v. Island Health
Decision Type:
APPLICATION FOR INTERIM STAY ORDER PENDING APPEAL
Decision Outcome:
GRANTED ON CONDITIONS
Act:
Community Care and Assisted Living Act
Date Decision Issued:
October 30, 2014
File Number:
2014-CCA-003
Decision Number:
2014-CCA-003(a)
File:
https://www.bcccalab.ca/app/uploads/sites/776/2020/07/2014cca003a.pdf
JM v. Island Health
Decision Type:
FINAL DECISION
Decision Outcome:
APPEAL DISMISSED
Act:
Community Care and Assisted Living Act
Date Decision Issued:
October 24, 2014
File Number:
2013-CCA-002
Decision Number:
2013-CCA-002(b)
File:
https://www.bcccalab.ca/app/uploads/sites/776/2020/07/2013cca002b.pdf
JM v. Island Health
Decision Type:
APPLICATION FOR INTERIM STAY ORDER PENDING APPEAL
Decision Outcome:
DENIED
Act:
Community Care and Assisted Living Act
Date Decision Issued:
December 13, 2013
File Number:
2013-CCA-002
Decision Number:
2013-CCA-002(a)
File:
https://www.bcccalab.ca/app/uploads/sites/776/2020/07/2013cca002a.pdf
AMS v. Vancouver Island Health Authority
Decision Type:
APPLICATION FOR DOCUMENT DISCLOSURE
Decision Outcome:
GRANTED
Act:
Community Care and Assisted Living Act
Date Decision Issued:
April 8, 2013
File Number:
2012-CCA-002
Decision Number:
2012-CCA-002(a)
File:
https://www.bcccalab.ca/app/uploads/sites/776/2020/07/2012cca002a.pdf
RKS v. Director, Early Childhood Educator Registry
Decision Type:
FINAL DECISION
Decision Outcome:
APPEAL DISMISSED
Act:
Community Care and Assisted Living Act
Date Decision Issued:
February 19, 2013
File Number:
2012-CCA-001
Decision Number:
2012-CCA-001(a)
File:
https://www.bcccalab.ca/app/uploads/sites/776/2020/07/2012cca001a.pdf
EK v. Director, Early Childhood Educator Registry
Decision Type:
FINAL DECISION
Decision Outcome:
APPEAL ALLOWED; REMITTED BACK TO RESPONDENT WITH DIRECTION
Act:
Community Care and Assisted Living Act
Date Decision Issued:
February 6, 2012
File Number:
2011-CCA-003
Decision Number:
2011-CCA-003(a)
File:
https://www.bcccalab.ca/app/uploads/sites/776/2020/07/2011cca003a.pdf
SNM v. Director, Early Childhood Educator Registry
Decision Type:
FINAL DECISION
Decision Outcome:
APPEAL ALLOWED IN PART; REMITTED TO RESPONDENT ON CONDITIONS
Act:
Community Care and Assisted Living Act
Date Decision Issued:
November 29, 2011
File Number:
2011-CCA-001
Decision Number:
2011-CCA-001(a)
File:
https://www.bcccalab.ca/app/uploads/sites/776/2020/07/2011cca001a.pdf
MC v. Fraser Health Authority
Decision Type:
FINAL DECISION
Decision Outcome:
APPEAL DISMISSED
Act:
Community Care and Assisted Living Act
Date Decision Issued:
June 13, 2011
File Number:
2010-CCA-006
Decision Number:
2010-CCA-006(a)
File:
https://www.bcccalab.ca/app/uploads/sites/776/2020/07/2010cca006a.pdf
AC v. Fraser Health Authority
Decision Type:
PRELIMINARY DECISION – JURISDICTION
Decision Outcome:
APPEAL REJECTED
Act:
Community Care and Assisted Living Act
Date Decision Issued:
February 1, 2011
File Number:
2010-CCA-009
Decision Number:
2010-CCA-009(a)
File:
https://www.bcccalab.ca/app/uploads/sites/776/2020/07/2010cca009a.pdf
North Shore Fun & Fitness Ltd v. Vancouver Coastal Health Authority
Decision Type:
ORDER
Decision Outcome:
TERMS OF SETTLEMENT INCORPORATED UNDER S. 17(2) ATA; APPEAL DISMISSED
Act:
Community Care and Assisted Living Act
Date Decision Issued:
December 21, 2010
File Number:
Decision Number:
File:
https://www.bcccalab.ca/app/uploads/sites/776/2020/07/north_shore.pdf
SH v. Fraser Health Authority
Decision Type:
FINAL DECISION
Decision Outcome:
APPEAL DISMISSED
Act:
Community Care and Assisted Living Act
Date Decision Issued:
November 17, 2010
File Number:
2009-CCA-003
Decision Number:
2010 BCCCALAB 8
File:
https://www.bcccalab.ca/app/uploads/sites/776/2020/07/2010_BCCCALAB_8.pdf
TF v. Chief Medical Health Officer, Northern Health Authority
Decision Type:
FINAL DECISION
Decision Outcome:
APPEAL DISMISSED
Act:
Community Care and Assisted Living Act
Date Decision Issued:
July 12, 2010
File Number:
2009-CCA-009
Decision Number:
2010 BCCCALAB 7
File:
https://www.bcccalab.ca/app/uploads/sites/776/2020/07/2010_BCCCALAB_7.pdf
MT v. Fraser Health Authority
Decision Type:
APPLICATION FOR SUMMARY DISMISSAL
Decision Outcome:
DENIED
Act:
Community Care and Assisted Living Act
Date Decision Issued:
May 25, 2010
File Number:
2009-CCA-007
Decision Number:
2010 BCCCALAB 6
File:
https://www.bcccalab.ca/app/uploads/sites/776/2020/07/2010_BCCCALAB_6.pdf
MM v. Medical Health Officer, Vancouver Coastal Health Services
Decision Type:
APPLICATION FOR INTERIM STAY
Decision Outcome:
DENIED
Act:
Community Care and Assisted Living Act
Date Decision Issued:
April 21, 2010
File Number:
2010-CCA-004
Decision Number:
2010 BCCCALAB 5
File:
https://www.bcccalab.ca/app/uploads/sites/776/2020/07/2010_BCCCALAB_5.pdf
AG v. Director, Early Childhood Educator Registry
Decision Type:
FINAL DECISION
Decision Outcome:
APPEAL DISMISSED
Act:
Community Care and Assisted Living Act
Date Decision Issued:
April 21, 2010
File Number:
2010-CCA-001
Decision Number:
2010 BCCCALAB 4
File:
https://www.bcccalab.ca/app/uploads/sites/776/2020/07/2010_BCCCALAB_4.pdf
SH v. Manager, Community Licensing
Decision Type:
ORDER REGARDING HEARING OF APPEAL
Decision Outcome:
Act:
Community Care and Assisted Living Act
Date Decision Issued:
March 8, 2010
File Number:
2009-CCA-003
Decision Number:
2010 BCCCALAB 3
File:
https://www.bcccalab.ca/app/uploads/sites/776/2020/07/2010_BCCCALAB_3.pdf
MT v. Director, Early Childhood Educator Registry
Decision Type:
FINAL DECISION
Decision Outcome:
APPEAL DISMISSED
Act:
Community Care and Assisted Living Act
Date Decision Issued:
March 1, 2010
File Number:
2009-CCA-006
Decision Number:
2010 BCCCALAB 2
File:
https://www.bcccalab.ca/app/uploads/sites/776/2020/07/2010_BCCCALAB_2.pdf
MR v. Director, Early Childhood Educator Registry
Decision Type:
FINAL DECISION
Decision Outcome:
APPEAL DISMISSED
Act:
Community Care and Assisted Living Act
Date Decision Issued:
January 19, 2010
File Number:
2009-CCA-004
Decision Number:
2010 BCCCALAB 1
File:
https://www.bcccalab.ca/app/uploads/sites/776/2020/07/2010_BCCCALAB_1.pdf
SH v. Manager, Community Licensing
Decision Type:
APPLICATION FOR ADJOURNMENT
Decision Outcome:
GRANTED
Act:
Community Care and Assisted Living Act
Date Decision Issued:
November 6, 2009
File Number:
2009-CCA-003
Decision Number:
2009 BCCCALAB 8
File:
https://www.bcccalab.ca/app/uploads/sites/776/2020/07/2009_BCCCALAB_8.pdf
SH v. Manager, Community Licensing
Decision Type:
APPLICATION TO REFUSE POSTPONEMENT
Decision Outcome:
DENIED
Act:
Community Care and Assisted Living Act
Date Decision Issued:
September 14, 2009
File Number:
2009-CCA-003
Decision Number:
2009 BCCCALAB 7
File:
https://www.bcccalab.ca/app/uploads/sites/776/2020/07/2009_BCCCALAB_7.pdf
SH v. Manager, Community Licensing
Decision Type:
APPLICATION FOR INTERIM STAY ORDER
Decision Outcome:
GRANTED ON CONDITIONS
Act:
Community Care and Assisted Living Act
Date Decision Issued:
July 24, 2009
File Number:
2009-CCA-003
Decision Number:
2009 BCCCALAB 6
File:
https://www.bcccalab.ca/app/uploads/sites/776/2020/07/2009_BCCCALAB_6.pdf
BD v. Early Childhood Educator Registry
Decision Type:
FINAL DECISION
Decision Outcome:
APPEAL DISMISSED
Act:
Community Care and Assisted Living Act
Date Decision Issued:
June 4, 2009
File Number:
2009-CCA-001
Decision Number:
2009 BCCCALAB 5
File:
https://www.bcccalab.ca/app/uploads/sites/776/2020/07/2009_BCCCALAB_5.pdf
GS and CAS v. Assisted Living Registrar
Decision Type:
FINAL DECISION
Decision Outcome:
APPEAL DISMISSED
Act:
Community Care and Assisted Living Act
Date Decision Issued:
June 1, 2009
File Number:
2008-CCA-020
Decision Number:
2009 BCCCALAB 4
File:
https://www.bcccalab.ca/app/uploads/sites/776/2020/07/2009_BCCCALAB_4.pdf
1
2
Next Page
Acts
Community Care and Assisted Living Act
(93)
